SFWRITER.COM > Nonfiction > Book Reviews > Dinosaur Hunters
Book Review
Dinosaur Hunters
Reviewed by Robert J. Sawyer
First published in Quill & Quire, March
1993
DINOSAUR HUNTERS, David A. E. Spalding; $29.25 hardcover
1-55013-300-4, 336 pp., 6x9, Key Porter Books, March
1993
Copyright © 1993 by
Robert J. Sawyer
All Rights Reserved
Everyone knows the names Tyrannosaurus and
Stegosaurus. With Dinosaur Hunters, David
Spalding, formerly with the Provincial Museum of Alberta, tries
to make the names of the people who discovered these ancient
giants equally well known.
Some individual dinosaur collectors have previously written
their own books or have had books devoted to them, but until now
there's been no volume summarizing the work of all major dinosaur
hunters past and present. Spalding's offering is a veritable
who's who of dinosaurian paleontology, sprinkled with intriguing
excerpts from fossil hunters' own diaries.
Unfortunately, it's precisely this wide scope that weakens
the book. Much of it reads like a catalog of names and dates.
Only occasionally does Spalding capture the quirky personalities
of dinosaur hunters, or make the reader's pulse quicken with
tales of hair-raising exploits. He does, however, do a good job
of debunking some apocryphal tales about paleontology's
most-famous figures.
The book is organized geographically; in flipping a single
page, we're taken jarringly from Philip Currie working today in
Alberta (the end of the North American section) to Roy Chapman
Andrews in Mongolia in the 1920s (the beginning of the Northern
Asia section). Because of this, it's hard to see how dinosaur
collecting has changed over the years. And several
paleontologists (including Ottawa's Dale Russell, who, as one of
the world's foremost dinosaur experts, surely merits a coherent
discussion) are scattered throughout the book, victims of not
having confined their work to Spalding's neat sections.
Dinosaur Hunters is a good, but not great, book that will
be best enjoyed by those who are already familiar with the
Mesozoic giants; very little space is devoted to facts about the
ancient beasts. This is solely the human side of the dinosaur
story. One could simply wish that it were a little more
human.
Robert J. Sawyer's latest science-fiction novel,
Fossil Hunter (Berkley/Ace, May
1993), is about an intelligent dinosaur who is himself a
paleontologist.
More Good Reading
Other book reviews by Robert J. Sawyer
My Very Occasional Newsletter
HOME • MENU • TOP
Copyright © 1995-2024 by Robert J. Sawyer.
|