SFWRITER.COM > Nonfiction > Book Reviews > Starcrosser
Book Review
Starcrosser
Reviewed by Robert J. Sawyer
Starcrosser by John Ibbitson, Collier
MacMillan, Toronto, 1990.
Reviewed by Robert J. Sawyer
First published in Canadian Book Review Annual
1990
Copyright © 1990 by
Robert J. Sawyer
All Rights Reserved
Starcrosser, a UFO abduction novel, is a book for junior
high school students. It's part of Collier MacMillan Canada's
"Series 2000," a collection of very short novels.
There's some funny, enjoyable material here, but I had real
problems with both the plot and the underlying philosophy.
Plot first: At the beginning of the book, the hero,
14-year-old Marshall Hampton, sticks a magnet on the side of his
Walkman portable cassette player. By the end of the book, weeks
later, the magnet is still there but the tape within has somehow
avoided being erased by it. Stretching credulity further, this
Walkman suddenly turns out to have a built-in speaker (such
portable tape players only have headphone jacks), so that
Marshall can reduce some nasty aliens to quivering jelly by
playing rock 'n' roll to them.
Beyond that, there's a morally reprehensible quality about
the lessons of the book. Marshall is whisked away form his home
in Sioux Lookout, Ontario, by alien Grophees who are at war with
the evil Drakonians. The Grophees assume that because Drakonians
look like humans, the humans must think like Drakonians. Rather
than being exposed as silly prejudice, this assumption is borne
out by the events of the story. And, although his conscience
occasionally pipes up with a platitude, Marshall decides to help
the Grophees, telling them how to mount a sneak attack against
the Drakonians. A friendly alien cries, "That is not honest!"
Marshall snaps back with some good old human wisdom: "Victory is
never honest."
There's some very brief lip service paid to the evils of
war, but it's all set aside when Marshall leads the Grophees and
their allies in a slaughter of the Drakonians.
It's a breezy read, but I can't recommend it as either
intelligent science fiction or as any kind of coherent morality
play.
More Good Reading
Other book reviews by Robert J. Sawyer
My Very Occasional Newsletter
HOME • MENU • TOP
Copyright © 1995-2024 by Robert J. Sawyer.
|